The place to go is Tally Ho, the finest Supper Club in Hayward, Wisconsin
With a proud family tradition of serving the community, Tally Ho Supper Club strives to be the best restaurant in the greater Hayward area. Our food is fresh, our menu scrumptious, and we treat our customers like members of our own family.
Open all-year round, we cater for private parties, weddings, and any function. We have a full to-go menu with curbside pick-up. You can check out our mouth-watering meal options online now.
Tally Ho Supper Club is a family-owned business, specializing in welcoming and serving your family and friends. We ensure that you will have the best dining experience, whatever the occasions. Special Holidays are marked with our famous five-course meals. We can tailor make a menu for your family or business functions or special event. We’ve just refurbished our restaurant for the upcoming summer season by adding outdoor dining. The Tally ho Supper Club is looking forward to welcoming you.
A special family member of Tally Ho Supper Club, Liam “Maverick” recently was diagnosed with acute lymphoid leukemia at just 18 Months old. Liam is fighting like a champion and all we can do is pray and support Liam and his family through treatment. Any and all help or donations are welcome and much appreciated.
- Upper 2/3 Choice Angus Ribeye
- Upper 2/3 Choice Angus
- Pork Porterhouse
- Lamb Chops
- Traditional Fish Boil – Atlantic Cod boiled with Potatos
- Deep Fried fish served with French fries, cole slaw & tartar sauce
- Seafood Tortellini
- Wild Caught Sea Scallops
- Freshwater Canadian Walleye
- Broiled Canadian Cold Water Lobster
- Deep Fried Frog Legs
Seasoned with our own dry rub and slow roasted.
Served with Au Jus.
12oz. Queen Cut or 16oz. King Cut
- Chicken Parmesan
- Chicken Alfredo
- Seven Cheese Lasagna
- Seafood Tortellini
- Veal Piccata
- Veal Parmesan
Items Listed on this website may not be available or have changed since the last site update
You can book our restaurant for any family occasion, or book the Gazibo for private partys, or join us in our holiday celebrations. Whether it’s Thanksgiving, Christmas, or Easter, we have a family-friendly menu with lots of different choices. Tally Ho Supper Club provides you a full tradition supper club menu including the authentic complimentary “supper club” relish tray.
In winter we welcome snows-port enthusiasts with our two full menus (Tally Ho & Tally Ho Gardens). During the summer, we are open Tuesday-Saturday for a full-menu and take-away service.
If you are organizing a special event, be sure to get in touch with us and we will tailor our menu to your requirements when organizing your private party or special event.
Please call for reservations to our restaurant so we can accomdate you. Thanks to our stringent cleaning routine and socially distanced setup, you can feel safe dining within our restaurant.